There does not have to have been any crisis which would
be universally viewed as traumatic; there does not have
to be a single causal event or mishap which is at the
root of all the individual's problems. Our problems may
be due to nothing more than the fact that when we are
born we are reared by people whose way of being is fundamentally
different from our own predisposition.
There does not have to be a 'villain of the piece', and
even when there is, it is not necessarily the case that
s/he is the cause of our client's difficulties. That said,
it is when we are confronted with the neuroses of others
during our formative years that most damage is done. It
is here that we find the roots of all the complexes, in
particular the masturbation and/or guilt complex, as well
as sublimated instinctive drives, embarrassment about
perfectly 'normal' behaviour patterns (dating, eating
in public, etc.), shame about body and bodily functions,
phobias (often by example: if mother is afraid of spiders,
then they must be creatures to be feared), general anxiety
(again, often learned by example), etc.
A neurotic parent will tend to produce a neurotic child;
two neurotic parents can scarcely do anything else. Even
where the behaviour of others during those formative years
has been emotionally and psychologically stable and therefore
non-injurious, even where nothing other than support and
encouragement has been extended towards the developing
individual, there may still be problems arising from the
developmental process.
An individual may struggle to solve problems with a firm,
no-nonsense attitude, because their family has insisted
that this is the way it must be - the Warrior instincts
- whilst they would secretly prefer to adopt a negotiating
or reconciliatory approach, that of the Settlers; they
might learn that practicality earns respect, whilst all
the time experiencing the imaginative, Nomadic, flights
of the creative mind; or perhaps be taught that it is
'normal' to be one of the general crowd, while every instinct
is that of the scholar, the introvert, with a thirst for
knowledge and understanding.
These and other contradictions can cause, at least, feelings
of uncertainty, at worst, feelings of being inadequate
or a misfit. If the 'secret' urges are eventually fulfilled,
then there will probably be no resultant neurosis; it
is when the individual suppresses them, that they make
their presence felt in the form of symptoms. Then, they
have often been denied for so long that there is no longer
any conscious knowledge of their existence, just a feeling
of being different in some way, which is often translated
as being 'odd' or 'weird'.
Attempts to change or modify any behavioural or thought
process without resolving any beliefs, mistaken or otherwise,
that are the cause of that behavioural or thought process
are likely to result in a long haul to emotional health
and may even then provide only a relatively temporary
respite from discomfort. The client's own resources are
at least as viable as the client's own conflicts and come
from the same root - the birth predisposition and early
experience. They just need finding, focusing upon, and
using.
The Initial Consultation
Whatever our therapeutic persuasions, the initial consultation
is an important time, both for client and therapist. The
client is seeking reassurance that their condition can
be helped; they are also anxious, believing that we have
more 'secret knowledge' than we actually do.
They can often imagine that every single word they say,
every gesture, stutter, twitch and intake of breath, every
shuffle of the foot, every hesitation for thought, may
be taken out of context and somehow assume great importance
as far as the therapist is concerned. They usually know
little or nothing of what we actually do, or how we do
it, and they may even fear that we are going to pronounce
them beyond help, or worse, possibly verging on some sort
of insanity. What we have to remember is, that in this
rarefied state of concentration and anxiety, which often
verges on hypnosis, our own behaviour is of paramount
importance. We can use the situation to engender transference,
overcome resistance, and give our client's belief system
a swift boost. In other words, we can make that all-important
'difference for today' that is going to set our client
on the road to a swift recovery even before we begin therapy.
These days, it is the swift recovery that is sought and,
in most cases, the swift recovery for which should conscientiously
strive.
Gathering Facts
Probably the most important part of this initial consultation
is the gathering of facts, from which we can assess whether
or not we have the necessary resources ourselves to help
the client, or if we should refer them on to either some
other form of therapy or orthodox medicine. The professional
must know his limitations and if s/he believes s/he doesn't
have any, then that is the biggest limitation of all.
There are three questions to which I always want the fullest
possible answers. 1. Details of the presenting symptom(s).
2. What the client wants therapy to achieve. 3. What they
feel is stopping them from achieving it on their own.
As far as question 1 is concerned, what it is, how long
it has existed, and what the client believes to be the
cause of it all are obviously essential information.
Symptoms are quite often coping mechanisms, like aerophobia
and claustrophobia (often related, of course) and we need
to look for associated hidden agendas or secondary gains.
Where the symptom serves no apparent purpose, though -
the fear of birds and moths, for instance, the indirect
symptom - we may not need to probe so deeply. The cause
is not particularly important, here, nor would it be easy
to find, so a more direct approach is indicated. Reframing
and the use of metaphor or fantasy are both useful approaches,
though there are obviously others. In all cases, though,
we need to discover the individual's own resources to
work with.
Question 2 is important, because it tells us whether the
client has realistic expectations of what we can do, or
if, instead, s/he is hoping for some sort of 'magic' to
be performed. I am never satisfied with a straightforward
'Want to get rid of my symptom' type of answer; I need
them to tell me how they want to be, how they want to
feel, what they want to be able to do that they can't
do now.